I was brought up on a staple diet of ' Indians are great human beings from a centuries old civilisation; while the westerners are upstarts with totally materialistic dispositions'. Well, I have seen light in the last about 20 years.
Generalisations are always wrong but here I am using them to make a point.
Indians seem to be about the most cruel, selfish and inhuman people you can ever come across. We rape young girls, slit the stomachs of young mothers, burn people by putting tyres around them and vandalise the helpless in ways a westerner can not even dream of. Our people in power - government, police, other officials etc - are actually the cause of all our miseries.There is absolutely no hope.
As for being materialistic, you just can't beat an Indian. And the bigger the tika on the forehead, the more materialistic the guy is.
On the other hand, westerners are pretty decent people.
Friday, July 9, 2010
Tuesday, June 15, 2010
Look inwards - hang the ugly Indian
There is too much emphasis on Anderson which suits the main culprits. Let us drop this focus on all things phoren and look inwards. The real problem is the ugly Indian. The guys who are responsible for the Bhopal people still drinking contaminated water, even as of today, are Indians. And they are in India,very accessible. In Krygystan, the people who tormented 120 Indian students may be foreigners but the embassy officials who treated them so inhumanly thereafter are all Indians. The guys who blocked the Manipur highway may be inaccessible goons but those who decided it was a matter not worthy of central intervention for 64 hellish days are all accessible Indians. It is also known that those who engineered this blockade are Indian marwari families of Imphal who benefited by blackmarketing scarce commodities during those days. Let us listen to Nehru and hang the black marketers, and other ugly Indians, by the nearest lamp post. The practical problem, though, is - how will you get so many lamp posts!
Let us clean up India even if it means letting go of Anderson. Charity must begin at home.
Let us clean up India even if it means letting go of Anderson. Charity must begin at home.
Monday, June 7, 2010
India's 'Success' on 26/11
I wrote the following lines just after the Mumbai terror attack ( 26/11 )
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mumbai terror incident and our responses thereof have been a microcosm of what the national security is today. Let us analyze it dispassionately.
Operational conduct of the anti terrorist operations was not at all effective. The very fact that it took around 300 NSG commandos, supported by MARCOS, the local military units and the whole state machinery to clean up 10 poorly trained, poorly equipped and poorly led civilians and that it took 3 days in doing so is proof itself. If someone claims that Kasab and friend were well trained, well armed and well led, one would be at a loss of adjectives for the equipment, training and professional leadership available to our security forces. The crowning glory came just a few days back when it was known that the terrorists managed to sleep one entire night after starting the mayhem!
Recently, one saw telecasts on Special forces ( Line of Fire – Times Now), NSG training ( Dhoni show ) and the glittering military might on 26 Jan. But what did they achieve during the Mumbai terror? They were neither able to deter the enemy, foil the attempt or counter it effectively.
Thereafter the country showed no spine in hitting out at where it itself claims the terrorists live and train. Some cost benefit exercise seems to have prevented the country from taking action. It is true that we have lost the military edge long back but that is no one else’s fault. All that our people see on a day to day basis is the sensex and cricket. So this loss of military differential obviously went unnoticed. Now, it is payback time and too late.
But if you think that cost benefit exercises are the way countries with honour behave, look South. Just next to us is the small island of Sri Lanka. At one point Sri Lankan army was being clearly pushed around by LTTE. But with national honour at stake, they decided to get up and get counted. It took them some decades and massive casualties to do so, but they retrieved their honour. Even if they hadn’t trounced LTTE and had perished in the effort, the world would have treated them with more respect than they will ever treat India. When one’s family members get raped, one has to get up and go after the rapists even if it is at unacceptable cost. We have consistently failed that test. We, who did not act when our parliament was attacked, did as has been our pattern.
And our people have shown that nothing can shake them out of their self induced tupor. For whom do the bells toll? The toll for thee and me. The VIPs have NSG security.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mumbai terror incident and our responses thereof have been a microcosm of what the national security is today. Let us analyze it dispassionately.
Operational conduct of the anti terrorist operations was not at all effective. The very fact that it took around 300 NSG commandos, supported by MARCOS, the local military units and the whole state machinery to clean up 10 poorly trained, poorly equipped and poorly led civilians and that it took 3 days in doing so is proof itself. If someone claims that Kasab and friend were well trained, well armed and well led, one would be at a loss of adjectives for the equipment, training and professional leadership available to our security forces. The crowning glory came just a few days back when it was known that the terrorists managed to sleep one entire night after starting the mayhem!
Recently, one saw telecasts on Special forces ( Line of Fire – Times Now), NSG training ( Dhoni show ) and the glittering military might on 26 Jan. But what did they achieve during the Mumbai terror? They were neither able to deter the enemy, foil the attempt or counter it effectively.
Thereafter the country showed no spine in hitting out at where it itself claims the terrorists live and train. Some cost benefit exercise seems to have prevented the country from taking action. It is true that we have lost the military edge long back but that is no one else’s fault. All that our people see on a day to day basis is the sensex and cricket. So this loss of military differential obviously went unnoticed. Now, it is payback time and too late.
But if you think that cost benefit exercises are the way countries with honour behave, look South. Just next to us is the small island of Sri Lanka. At one point Sri Lankan army was being clearly pushed around by LTTE. But with national honour at stake, they decided to get up and get counted. It took them some decades and massive casualties to do so, but they retrieved their honour. Even if they hadn’t trounced LTTE and had perished in the effort, the world would have treated them with more respect than they will ever treat India. When one’s family members get raped, one has to get up and go after the rapists even if it is at unacceptable cost. We have consistently failed that test. We, who did not act when our parliament was attacked, did as has been our pattern.
And our people have shown that nothing can shake them out of their self induced tupor. For whom do the bells toll? The toll for thee and me. The VIPs have NSG security.
Thursday, May 27, 2010
Government versus its soldiers
Here is one more shocker about how the govt treats its soldiers. Officers holding the rank of Capt to Brig as on 01-01-1986 suffered significant cumulative losses in pay/pension since successive pay commissions had used wrong data for fixing the pay scales. This issue had been going on in courts for some years. Recently the Supreme Court granted relief to all such officers, with 6 % interest on arrears. Having read this news, we were very sure that now we will get our dues. However, it shocked us to be told that the govt has gone in for appeal against the SC order.
Were we too naive to assume that the govt should have no problems in paying us our dues, particularly when the highest court has okayed its legality? Actually, good governments should be finding ways to pay their soldiers well irrespective of the legal position but here the opposite is true.
Would this leave soldiers with a high regard for their government? You judge.
I am quite clear that I am not proud of my government.
Were we too naive to assume that the govt should have no problems in paying us our dues, particularly when the highest court has okayed its legality? Actually, good governments should be finding ways to pay their soldiers well irrespective of the legal position but here the opposite is true.
Would this leave soldiers with a high regard for their government? You judge.
I am quite clear that I am not proud of my government.
Tuesday, May 18, 2010
Op GreenHunt - Right or Wrong?
Anything wrong with the government's decision to launch op Greenhunt to combat Naxalism? Yes and No. Of course, use of force is the only way. To that extent, it is a bold decision that only Congress led government could have taken. BJP, which is crying hoarse with their 'half a battle' remark mobilised the whole army after the Parliament attack but called it off after several months without a shot being fired. So, well done, UPA.
However, the problem is that the HM has not been able to assess the battle worthiness of his para military forces before tasking them. It has been quite like Mr Nehru saying before the 62 war that ' I have ordered the army to throw out the Chinese'. Para military forces are poorly led, poorly trained and poorly kitted. It is easy to blame units for violating the SOPs. However, SOPs regarding not visiting villages are implementable only if the units are so well administered that they do not have to depend on villages for day to day survival. That is far from being the case. Not only the para military, we have seen even the army men having to enter combat without full authorized equipment.
Our men are as valiant as any in the world, only our leadership is not worthy of them.
However, the problem is that the HM has not been able to assess the battle worthiness of his para military forces before tasking them. It has been quite like Mr Nehru saying before the 62 war that ' I have ordered the army to throw out the Chinese'. Para military forces are poorly led, poorly trained and poorly kitted. It is easy to blame units for violating the SOPs. However, SOPs regarding not visiting villages are implementable only if the units are so well administered that they do not have to depend on villages for day to day survival. That is far from being the case. Not only the para military, we have seen even the army men having to enter combat without full authorized equipment.
Our men are as valiant as any in the world, only our leadership is not worthy of them.
Sunday, May 2, 2010
Crime committed but no criminals
Why are some of us so amazed that some radio active pencils have been lost by Delhi University and no one has been able to trace then till now. Or that the killers of Arushi have still not been caught.
Ours is a country where thousand of Sikhs could be massacred over several days, hundreds of muslims could be torched and a masjid could be brought down in full view of hundreds of policemen and a few dozen senior officers. That these things happened is not so detestable - human beings will be cruel. What is being pointed out is that when perpetrators of crimes of this magnitude, carried out in broad daylight over several days can not be traced for several decades, should expect anything better this time?
Ours is a country where thousand of Sikhs could be massacred over several days, hundreds of muslims could be torched and a masjid could be brought down in full view of hundreds of policemen and a few dozen senior officers. That these things happened is not so detestable - human beings will be cruel. What is being pointed out is that when perpetrators of crimes of this magnitude, carried out in broad daylight over several days can not be traced for several decades, should expect anything better this time?
Hang only Kasab? Great mistake.
The overwhelming desire of the Indian people to see Kasab hanged is understandable. What is not, however, is their indifference towards inaction by the state against those who helped Kasab succeed. I am referring to the policemen who ran away from CST, senior officers who for years did nothing to improve the capabilities of the police and NSG force and national leaders who did nothing after the parliament and other previous attacks on India. All of them helped Kasab succeed more than those who trained him. Hanging Kasab alone will as good as ensure we have another such incident pretty soon. In acting only against Kasab, we will behave as our own worst enemy.
This reminds me of something I read somewhere long ago. It seems that the culprit of the great train robbery ( England ) was being escorted by policemen to court. In the same area, Lord Balaclava ( the person who ordered the unprofessional 'charge of the light brigade' resulting in hundreds of needless deaths, but was romanticized by media ) was being garlanded. Seeing this the train robber sighed,'This is luck. I am being incarcerated for merely stealing some money. But the guy who caused a few hundred deaths is being honoured. Alas'.
This reminds me of something I read somewhere long ago. It seems that the culprit of the great train robbery ( England ) was being escorted by policemen to court. In the same area, Lord Balaclava ( the person who ordered the unprofessional 'charge of the light brigade' resulting in hundreds of needless deaths, but was romanticized by media ) was being garlanded. Seeing this the train robber sighed,'This is luck. I am being incarcerated for merely stealing some money. But the guy who caused a few hundred deaths is being honoured. Alas'.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
